The Not-So-Great-Bake-Along '26 - Week 8
It’s caramel week - my absolute nemesis!
I’d managed to somehow block that horrific summer heatwave out of my brain (largely because the weather’s turned cold and I hate it) but it all came roaring back this week - that was not the weather for nougatine or feuilletine or any sort of ‘tine’, quite frankly. And yet, somehow, we mostly didn’t get total disasters!
I’m so happy that Moyin got a star baker (although Harry Potter was involved - gross) and Connie leaving was so sweet. But the technical - an all-around exception to the lack of disasters. Again - if they all cock it up, it’s not the baker’s faults!
As a result, I did things a little differently this week. Largely because, in the end, I wanted to end up with a lot of edible millionaire’s shortbread.
The Rules:
- I have to recreate, to the best of my ability, the Technical Challenge.
- I will not be looking at any kind of recipe. Each week, I have to do this purely with some context from the show and my own store of baking knowledge.
- The time limit: The maximum amount of time I’ll be allowing myself is the time given to the bakers. Unless the time limit given clearly doesn’t work; this week, I made some allowances.
- The judging: I still have a distinct lack of gingham altar and (thankfully) Paul Hollywood in my life. My partner and his officemates are not complaining about their continued judging responsibilities.
- The equipment: I like to think I’ve got the sort of decently-stocked kitchen any skilled home baker would have. If a technical challenge requires specialist equipment I don’t have, I won’t be buying anything for the occasion. I will be MacGyvering it, and adjusting my handicaps accordingly.
Caramel Week - Millionaires Shortbread
Starting with the timer set for an hour and a half - and I’m fully aware that I will be ignoring it when it does finally go off.
Shortbread is, at least, simple. Butter and sugar, then flour, and hastily pressed into a tin. I do not try to make it perfectly even because life is short and I am incredibly lazy. It takes nine minutes to get it made and into the oven - and it needs at least twenty to bake. Already, the maths is not looking great on this one.
Next up: caramel. A cruel mistress. A vicious bastard. Vindictive viscosity in the form of melted sugar. Still, we soldier bravely on. The sugar, unfortunately, can’t be hurried in its melting - and here’s where I start getting incredibly frustrated by this challenge.
It’s caramel week - so the caramel is surely key here. The challenge is, really, ‘can you make nice caramel that’s neatly set between two layers of other stuff?’ The answer, for me at least, is usually yes. But under this time crunch, the challenge becomes ‘can you speed-run caramel and magically make a shortbread cool down instantaneously?’ The answer to both of those questions, for both me and the bakers, is ‘fuck off can I.’
Anyway, I melt some sugar. I add cream and butter and cook it ‘til it looks just about right (I still refuse to buy a sugar thermometer). Still, this now has to cool down a bit - as does the shortbread - because if I combine hot caramel and a hot biscuit the results might be delicious but I’m sure as hell not going to get something that sets into neat, separate layers.
I have thirty-five minutes to go by the time I have the shortbread and caramel at the right temperatures, combined and in the freezer. I’ve added a little sprinkle of flaky salt to the top of the caramel layer, because I’m just that sort of person.
Melting the chocolate proves to be a ballache, as I’ve only got two bowls that I can set over pans of water, but I manage something like a decent temper on the dark chocolate and let out a spectacular scream of profanity every time I think about the vast amounts of washing-up that will need doing when this is all over.
With fifteen minutes to go, the caramel’s set enough to add the chocolate, and I stick the whole lot back in the freezer.
Now, if I’d made that layer of chocolate wafer-thin, the whole thing might just have been done in time, but the end result would have been a shit millionaire’s shortbread. I want something delicious at the end of this, so fuck that nonsense.
With two minutes to go, I pull the thing out of the freezer and face the dilemma. The chocolate is still liquid. On the show, I’d have no choice but to cut it anyway and serve up a disaster - such as the ones we saw. However, I’m not on television, and the thought of the clean-up sends me into a conniption. Instead, I stick the whole thing back in the freezer and time how long it takes to be set enough to cut.
It turns out, all I needed was an extra fifteen minutes.
The Judging
Look, what I’ve dished up is banging. The shortbread’s perfectly buttery, the caramel is rich and delightful without gluing my teeth together, and there’s exactly the right amount of chocolate. Admittedly, the layers are less-than-perfect in places, and I’ll mark myself down to an 8 for appearance there, but the flavour’s a 10.
My partner doesn’t give a fuck about layers, and gives me tens across the board. One of his colleagues describes them as ‘the bollocks’, but my partner texts me that without any context and I’m left wondering why his workmates feel the need to send me messages about their testicles. Such is life.
So, was this a fair challenge? Was it fuck!
I did look back over everything, trying to see if I could have found that extra fifteen minutes somewhere. I could have been a bit quicker with the shortbread, and maybe clawed back a couple of minutes there. That’s about it. I could have started melting the sugar for the caramel sooner - but I still would have had to cool the biscuit before the caramel went on, so that would have honestly meant very little. I specifically timed melting the chocolate so it would be ready just as the caramel was set - there was no time to be clawed back there.
Five minutes. I could maybe shave off five minutes overall, and dished up something almost as good. Which means giving the bakers and extra ten minutes could have made this a challenge about caramel, not about the miserable inevitability of failure.
Next week, patisserie!