The Not-So-Great-Bake-Along '26 - Week 9
It’s patisserie week! Time to struggle with spelling/pronouncing words like ‘patisserie’ and ‘gateaux’ and (spoilers) somehow cock up meringues in multiple ways! A delight!
I was stressed watching this episode and having flashbacks to the summer heatwave. How any of the bakers managed to make literally anything is totally beyond me - I would have simply given up and locked myself in the fridge. I was unbelievably gutted to see Gabe go. I don’t care if he deserved it or not. I’ve been kinda rooting for nonchalant Mo, but that definitely ended this week when he uttered the phrase ‘I asked ChatGPT’. Don’t ask ChatGPT. No good can come of it.
Anyway, Gâteaux Concorde. Chocolate meringue and chocolate mousse. Two things I’ve made many times before, and I had the great luxury of working in normal temperatures. How complicated could this really be?
The Rules:
- I have to recreate, to the best of my ability, the Technical Challenge.
- I will not be looking at any kind of recipe. Each week, I have to do this purely with some context from the show and my own store of baking knowledge.
- The time limit: The maximum amount of time I’ll be allowing myself is the time given to the bakers. Sometimes I’ll scale down the bakes and adjust the time limit accordingly. I should have done that this week.
- The judging: I still have a distinct lack of gingham altar and (thankfully) Paul Hollywood in my life. My partner and his officemates are not complaining about their continued judging responsibilities.
- The equipment: I like to think I’ve got the sort of decently-stocked kitchen any skilled home baker would have. If a technical challenge requires specialist equipment I don’t have, I won’t be buying anything for the occasion. I will be MacGyvering it, and adjusting my handicaps accordingly.
Pâtisserie Week - Gâteaux Concorde
So - Meringue’s first. Again, this is something I’ve made a lot. We used to serve giant meringues at my last job and they looked fantastic - big fluffy, and surprisingly low effort clouds.
So I duly separate my eggs and whisk and add the sugar and I’m even good about using a sieve to get the icing sugar and cocoa powder in there and folding it in properly. These are going to be perfect meringues, I’m sure. I’m not even slightly worried about this part of the challenge - it’s the chocolate mousse that’s concerning me but that’s a minute off.
Then comes time to pipe the meringue, and things start going tits up.
Do you ever have those days where you’re perhaps a little sleep-deprived, perhaps mentally juggling a small dog in Edo-era Japan, a post-apocalyptic gemstone-filled landscape and some comedy goblins (I’m doing narrative design now and I love it ever so), perhaps just not really functioning enough for patisserie, and your brain and hands decide to operate on two different wavelengths?
This was very much my experience. The meringue mix didn’t want to be in the piping bag. The piping bag wanted to overflow out of the wrong end. The baking parchment didn’t want to lay still (at one point a sheet of it decided to start sliding off the tray and threatened to land on the floor).
Somehow, I get three discs of meringue and some nice long lines on the trays.
Then things really start going wrong. At one point I gave up on piping, and just spread the meringue on the tray. That one will prove, later, to be far too thin, and break apart the moment I try to add it to the ‘cake’.
Next problem: My oven only has two racks. I decide I can get away with putting a tray directly on the bottom. I plan on shifting things round halfway through cooking.
When I do that, I knock a chunk off one of the other trays of meringue.
The one that remains on the bottom of the oven burns - this was not a suitable way to cook a meringue.
All in all, that’s three different meringues cocked up in three unique ways. It’s a triumph, of a sort. Specifically, of the sort that gives me a minor mental breakdown.
Let’s go back then, to the meringues first going in the oven (somehow I’m 25 minutes down at this point) and the beginnings of the chocolate mousse - the bit I’m actually worried about.
I’ve made many a chocolate mousse before, but not using this method. I can confirm that this method - whisking sugar syrup into egg yolk and the like - makes a fantastic chocolate mousse, and I’ll never be doing it again.
I’ve got egg yolks whisking away in my stand mixer. I’m whipping cream in another bowl. Chocolate is in yet another bowl melting over a bain-marie, and I’ve got a pan of sugar syrup on the hob. There are too many bowls and whisking/stirring things happening at once, and I don’t like it.
Still, the cream whips without incident. The sugar syrup goes in the egg yolks without incident, and whips up to a lovely pale ribbon texture. I remember to cool the chocolate a bit before adding it to the egg mixture (I think this might have been where Moyin went wrong) and this also passes without incident. Folding in the whipped cream passes without incident. I end up with an incredible chocolate mousse - really, one of the best I’ve ever made, and I could eat the entire bowl of stuff without trouble. I’m delighted - I’ve got an hour and a half to go, and this challenge is really passing without incident.
Then I smell burning, and realise my meringue error.
I consider, briefly, binning off this whole challenge. This is my usual reaction to even the smallest of inconveniences, and I think that’s perfectly reasonable. (Also, in this case, if I bin off the whole challenge, I can just eat that chocolate mousse. Really. Just shove my face in the bowl and go at it. It’s very, very tempting.)
But I rally myself, knock up another meringue, and pipe it with less incident this time. With an hour and ten minutes to go I take the two not-burnt meringues out and shove the emergency back-up meringue in. If I can get away with only cooking that one for 50 minutes, that gives me twenty minutes to cool it and add it to the cake at the end.
I crack on with assembling what I can. The first meringue layer - the one with a chunk missing - goes at the bottom. A layer of chocolate mousse goes in. The second layer of meringue - the fragile, skinny one, goes in in pieces. It’ll do. More chocolate mousse, and with fifty minutes to go I’ve got nothing to do but wait, and let that chill.
Well, I can cut some meringue cylinders. They are not all equally sized. Many of them explode into shards. I am not cut out for the precision of patisserie and you know what? I’m alright with that.
The emergency meringue comes out with twenty minutes to go, and I give it five minutes before starting on the final assembly.
Really, it’s a bit tight on the chocolate mousse, and I’m sad about the lack of leftovers, but this is the kind of thing we must suffer. I barely have enough meringue cylinders, but I sort-of make it work.
With three minutes to go, I’m done. Safe in the knowledge that I’ll never tackle one of these bastards again, I dig in.
The Judging.
My partner gives me a 9 for appearance, and comments that the meringue cylinders look like fencing. I’m not sure what to do with that information. He gives me a 9.5 for flavour, explaining that it would be a 10 but he feels he has to mark me down because he knows I fucked up. Rude, but I’ll take it.
I’m giving myself a 7 for appearance - the ‘fencing’ is wonky as hell, and with that puzzle-piece meringue in the middle there aren’t exactly distinctive layers. It’s a 9 for flavour because I don’t want to be too nice to myself.
Was this a fair challenge? I’ll say yes, but with an asterisk.
Look, this was doable in the timeframe, and that was including me making that extra emergency meringue. It would be more challenging in ridiculous temperatures, yes, but as long as you’re working quickly whenever you’re dealing with things at room temperature, it shouldn’t be a struggle to make that mousse set.
But. Paul Hollywood make a comment that ‘we’ve given them extra time for chilling, because of the heat.’ That leads me to guess that they weren’t going to be given two and a half hours for this challenge. In two hours, it would be a completely different story. This felt like a fair challenge, but it feels like it wasn’t intended to be.
Next week - it’s finally the final! What nonsense will I have to endure?